Main content

Phantom Form Guide: August

Connor McFadyen has proven himself to be amongst Brisbane's leading Academy prospects this year. - Brisbane Lions,Draft
Connor McFadyen has proven himself to be amongst Brisbane's leading Academy prospects this year.

The NAB AFL Draft continues to edge closer, which makes it a good time to update our Phantom Form Guide.

The ranking of the best players in this year's pool does not take into account where the prospects may get selected or where bids may come on father-son or Academy players. It is purely our view on who are the top group available in 2018.

This is the second Phantom Form Guide of the year, and we will update it monthly in the lead-up to November's national draft.

POS: Midfielder
Ht 183cm, Wt 74kg, DOB 2/7/00
From Geelong Falcons/Vic Country

Walsh just continues to motor on, piecing together one of the most complete and consistent seasons seen in recent years for an under-18 prospect. Since the national carnival Walsh has played for the Geelong Falcons and dominated two weeks ago when he picked up 33 disposals, six tackles, six clearances and six inside-50s against the Oakleigh Chargers (the next most on the ground had 24 touches). He has a strong endurance base, kicks the ball well and has found a good balance between winning it himself and providing run. A gun. 

POS: Tall forward
Ht 194cm, Wt 85kg, DOB 9/8/00
From Woodville-West Torrens/South Australia

Many recruiters will have Lukosius at No.1 on their board and with good reason. The key forward is one of the best of his type to have come through the draft in the past few years. He leads smartly and continues to present all game, working up the ground to get the ball and then back closer to goal to be a threat. Lukosius has played in the SANFL senior side all season and kicked two goals from 14 touches and eight marks (plus he had five tackles) for Woodville-West Torrens in its important win over North Adelaide in July. 

POS: Half-forward/midfielder
Ht 180cm, Wt 76kg, DOB 23/4/00
From West Adelaide/South Australia

Rankine hasn't blown anyone away with his form since the under-18 championships, but he has done more than enough over the past two years to highlight his talents. The brilliant half-forward/midfielder lit up the final game of the national carnival with a devastating five-goal display and it encompassed all of his best traits: sharp skills, uncanny goalkicking ability, a sense of the occasion and genuine pace. It's going to be fun watching him next year, and beyond.

Izak Rankine might be the most exciting player in the draft. 

POS: Tall forward
Ht 202cm, Wt 86kg, DOB 7/7/00
From Sandringham Dragons/Vic Metro

King is more than three months on from his knee reconstruction after suffering an anterior cruciate ligament tear while playing school football. The next step in his rehabilitation is to get back running. King, a high-marking key forward who kicked eight goals earlier this season in a commanding game for the Sandringham Dragons, would have vied for the No.1 pick if not for the season-ending injury. He is using St Kilda's facilities two days a week as part of his fitness program. 

POS: Midfielder
Ht 186cm, Wt 82kg, DOB 7/12/00
From Sandringham Dragons/Vic Metro 

An Achilles injury has kept Smith out of action the past two weeks, but he'll be keen to get back out there soon to finish off what has been an excellent season. Some recruiters have Smith in the No.1 pick conversation, such has been his capacity to impact games this season. He has a lot going for him as a modern midfielder given his size, endurance, speed and power. As hard-working and relentless as any player in the pool.

POS: Tall forward/defender
Ht 202cm, Wt 85kg, DOB 7/7/00
From Sandringham Dragons/Vic Metro 

King has spent the majority of this season forward since his brother Max's knee reconstruction, and Ben now favours it as his preferred position. He kicked seven goals two weeks ago for school side Haileybury matched up against Will Kelly, who shapes as a possible top-30 pick and was in good form. King is a deadeye in front of goal, almost unbeatable on the lead and with some extra size on him once at an AFL club he will be difficult to stop in the air. Given his ability to play at both ends of the ground he's a very appealing choice. 

POS: Tall forward/midfielder
Ht 195cm, Wt 80kg, DOB 27/2/00
From Sydney Swans Academy/Allies 

Blakey has missed some footy in the aftermath of the championships with some bone bruising in his left ankle. Blakey looks likely to cost the Swans their first pick at the draft as an Academy selection. He showed during the championships he could play as a tall forward and also in the midfield, where he moved in the Allies' final game and highlighted his strengths. A left-footer who is agile at ground level for his height.

Nick Blakey is bound for the Swans at the 2018 draft. 

POS: Half-forward/midfielder
Ht 185cm, Wt 71kg, DOB 22/1/00
From North Adelaide/South Australia

After an under-18 championships where he didn't reach his best, Rozee went back to North Adelaide and pieced together one of his best games of the season. The exciting half-forward/midfielder kicked three goals for its senior side and also laid four tackles against South Adelaide. Rozee might not have had the most consistent season but he remains one of the most talented players in it: he can jump, take big marks, land on his feet and get things going. Things tend to happen when he has the ball and he should be an early pick. 

POS: Midfielder
Ht 184cm, Wt 78kg, DOB 28/9/00
From Bendigo Pioneers/Vic Country 

Caldwell's championships was ruined by a hamstring injury, which saw him miss five weeks of footy. But the tough midfielder returned at school level at the end of last month and immediately showed his class to recruiters, some of whom went to the game just to watch him play. Caldwell is a tough, inside midfielder with a robust attitude and application to the game. He has the physicality to bust through and past players and should be seen as being in the best group of ball-winners available. 

POS: Midfielder
Ht 189cm, Wt 73kg, DOB 25/3/00
From North Launceston/Tasmania/Allies 

It emerged after the division one championships that Thomas had been carrying a thumb strain and some bone bruising throughout the carnival. He took a couple of weeks off but returned recently for North Launceston. Thomas' championships for the Allies was a little underwhelming after he had starred for Tasmania earlier in the year at the under-18 Academy series. Thomas is a tough midfielder with good skills who can also play as a half-back or half-forward. 

POS: Half-back
Ht 182cm, Wt 82kg, DOB 15/1/00
From Oakleigh Chargers/Vic Metro

Quaynor is a dependable type of defender who can match up on most types of forwards. He's quick and agile enough to play on the smaller options, and he can also shut down players who have height and size on him. He was named an All Australian after a solid under-18 carnival and has been consistent for the Oakleigh Chargers across the season.

POS: Midfielder
Ht 190cm, Wt 81kg, DOB 21/10/00
From Central District/South Australia 

The midfielder has performed well at senior level for Central District across the season. Hately's appeal will come in his body size: at 190cm he is a big midfielder who uses the ball well, collects plenty of it and can also push forward. Hately seems to fit into the second bracket of midfielders in this year's pool and clubs will look at him as a player who could make an impact next year.

POS: Half-forward/midfielder
Ht 186cm, Wt 79kg, DOB 6/4/00
From Calder Cannons/Vic Metro

A knee injury that Taylor played through during the national carnival for Vic Metro meant he took a bit longer to get back to playing for the Cannons. Taylor is a classy user of the ball, smart overhead and clever around goal, and you trust when he has it in his hands that something good will come of the disposal. He's not a huge possession-winner and hasn't played in the midfield as much as recruiters might have hoped to see. But as a half-forward there are few better than him in the draft. 

POS: Midfielder/half-forward
Ht 175cm, Wt 76kg, DOB 9/2/00
From Perth/Western Australia

It hasn't been a dominant season for Hill, who missed the final game of the under-18 championships through suspension. However, the exciting West Australian has shown flashes of his talent throughout the year and remains one of the most eye-catching players in the pool when he's up and going. The second cousin of Freo pair Stephen and Bradley, Hill is small and plays across half-forward but eventually thinks he can bring his run and carry game into the midfield.

There are some fine genes in Ian Hill's footballing DNA. 

POS: Midfielder
Ht 180cm, Wt 80kg, DOB 12/7/00
From Calder Cannons/Vic Metro

The Western Bulldogs father-son prospect is one of the most regular ball-winners in the draft, particularly in the games that matter. His performances for Vic Metro at the under-18 carnival saw him named an All Australian, and he is good at digging in and getting his hands on the ball. He also likes to get forward and fly for a mark when he can. West can float in and out of games, but when he puts his mind to it he's hard to stop in the middle.

POS: Midfielder
Ht 181cm, Wt 70kg, DOB 8/9/00
From Western Jets/Vic Metro

Butters underwent shoulder surgery in July after carrying the injury as long as he could through the under-18 championships. It wouldn't surprise if he dropped a little down the draft order because of the injury layoff, but he is a smart, savvy player who runs with the ball and uses it well by foot. He defies his size by having a big impact on game through his line-breaking movement and capacity to also snag a goal or two.

POS: Midfielder
Ht 193cm, Wt 88kg, DOB 3/2/00
From Oakleigh Chargers/Vic Metro

For an inside midfielder Collier-Dawkins doesn't have the type of big possession games that you might expect. But he does influence games with his touches, which come mainly by hand. Two weeks ago for the Chargers he had 15 disposals but only one was a kick. He also had 10 tackles that day, highlighting his work rate around the ground. Collier-Dawkins is a tall midfielder who can also push forward, but he trusts his handballing more than his kicking at this stage. He will appeal as a player who could develop into a clearance star. 

POS: Midfielder
Ht 180cm, Wt 74kg, DOB 14/1/00
From Launceston/Tasmania/Allies 

Jones is a dependable player who can be used in a myriad of roles. Hard-working runner who plays his best footy through the midfield, where he has neat skills and is a competitor. Jones didn't dominate the under-18 carnival but put out some good showings and can also be played as a smaller forward or back. Is tough, committed and determined.

Chayce Jones is one of the draft's most versatile prospects.

POS: Key defender
Ht 193cm, Wt 83kg, DOB 16/8/00
From Oakleigh Chargers/Vic Metro

Kelly has improved from the start of the season to be in the mix as a top-30 pick on draft night. He played a terrific game for the Oakleigh Chargers several weeks ago in which he gathered 21 touches, eight marks and four rebound-50s in their win over Calder. Two weeks ago he was beaten by Ben King, who kicked seven goals, but Kelly still won some good one-on-ones. He's athletic, big and strong and you can see him fitting in to an AFL backline.

POS: Midfielder
Ht 190cm, Wt 88kg, DOB 4/12/00
From Brisbane Lions Academy/Queensland/Allies

McFadyen has proven himself to be Brisbane's leading Academy prospect this year after a consistent season. He took his game to another level in the Allies' division one carnival and was named an All Australian for his efforts after averaging 17 disposals (nine contested) during the carnival. He is a big and strong midfielder who excels at the stoppages and has also shown good form in the Lions' NEAFL side. Comes from an elite junior cricket background.

POS: Half-back
Ht 183cm, Wt 81kg, DOB 7/9/00
From Central District/South Australia

McLennan's trick is his intercept marking. Despite not being of key position size, McLennan is very good at reading the play in the back half and cutting off forward forays. It's what he does better than anyone else in the pool. He averaged five marks and 13 disposals a game for SA during the championships, and recently made his debut for Central District's senior side in the SANFL.

POS: Half-back
Ht 182cm, Wt 78kg, DOB 16/10/00
From Claremont/Western Australia

Clark was Western Australia's best-performed player at the under-18 carnival, when he averaged 19.5 touches a game and five rebound-50s. it saw him claim his state's MVP award and All Australian selection. Clark is a running backman who is trusted to set up the play and get things going out of the defensive half. A smart footballer who sees – and makes – the play unfold.

Jordan Clark was WA's best player at the national carnival. Picture: AFL Photos

POS: Midfielder
Ht 185cm, Wt 71kg, DOB 7/7/00
From Gippsland Power/Vic Country

An attacking half-back and midfielder who has performed consistently for the Power across the season and also put in some strong games for Vic Country at the under-18 championships. Can stride down the ground and take the ball with him. Xavier's uncle Jamie Duursma played 59 games for Sydney, Brisbane and Melbourne in the 1980s, including the Demons' 1988 Grand Final defeat.

POS: Midfielder
Ht 186cm, Wt 80kg, DOB 8/5/00
From Norwood/South Australia

Valente doesn't do a lot wrong. His highlight reel may not be quite as thrilling as others', but he has been a consistent and prolific player across the season. The midfielder captained South Australia's triumph at the under-18 carnival, was named its most valuable player and also claimed All Australian honours after averaging 23 disposals at 84 per cent during the carnival.

POS: Ruckman/tall forward
Ht 198cm, Wt 95kg, DOB 17/4/00
From Dandenong Stingrays/Vic Country

Clubs are still divided as to whether they see Williams as a key forward who goes into the ruck, a ruckman who can float forward or a good mix of both. Any which way, Williams hasn't dominated this season like he might have hoped to. He is a nice kick for goal and can take a good overhead grab when he goes forward.

2018 Indicative Draft Order

AFL Media has put together the draft order based on the ladder positions following Round 20.

Based on the Lions' current ladder position it is predicted the Club will hold picks 3, 21, 39, 57 and 75. 

Take a look at the indicative draft order below:

CARL 1. Carlton
GCFC 2. Gold Coast
BL 3. Brisbane
STK 4. St Kilda
WB 5. Western Bulldogs
FRE 6. Fremantle
ADEL 7. Adelaide
ESS 8. Essendon
NMFC 9. North Melbourne
GEEL 10. Geelong
SYD 11. Sydney
PORT 12. Port Adelaide
COLL 13. Collingwood
HAW 14. Hawthorn
ADEL 15. Adelaide (received from Melbourne)
GWS 16. Greater Western Sydney 
GCFC 17. Gold Coast (received from West Coast)
RICH 18. Richmond

ADEL 19. Adelaide (received from Carlton)
WCE 20. West Coast (received from Gold Coast)
BL 21. Brisbane
PORT 22. Port Adelaide (received from St Kilda)
CARL 23. Carlton (received from Western Bulldogs)
GWS 24. Greater Western Sydney (received from Fremantle)
CARL 25. Carlton (received from Adelaide)
GCFC 26. Gold Coast (received from Essendon)
NMFC 27. North Melbourne
GCFC 28. Gold Coast (received from Geelong)
SYD 29. Sydney
PORT 30. Port Adelaide
SYD 31. Sydney (received from Collingwood)
HAW 32. Hawthorn
MELB 33. Melbourne
ESS 34. Essendon (received from Greater Western Sydney)
WCE 35. West Coast
RICH 36. Richmond

ADEL 37. Adelaide (received from Carlton)
GCFC 38. Gold Coast
BL 39. Brisbane
NMFC 40. North Melbourne (received from St Kilda via on-trades)
WB 41. Western Bulldogs
GCFC 42. Gold Coast (received from Fremantle)
MELB 43. Melbourne (received from Adelaide)
GWS 44. Greater Western Sydney (received from Essendon)
PORT 45. Port Adelaide (received from North Melbourne)
GEEL 46. Geelong
COLL 47. Collingwood (received from Sydney)
PORT 48. Port Adelaide
COLL 49. Collingwood
HAW 50. Hawthorn
MELB 51. Melbourne
GWS 52. Greater Western Sydney 
NMFC 53. North Melbourne (received from West Coast via on-trades)
GEEL 54. Geelong (received from Richmond)

GEEL 55. Geelong (received from Carlton)
GEEL 56. Geelong (received from Gold Coast)
BL 57. Brisbane
STK 58. St Kilda
WB 59. Western Bulldogs
WB 60. Western Bulldogs (received from Fremantle)
STK 61. St Kilda (received from Adelaide via on-trades)
ESS 62. Essendon
NMFC 63. North Melbourne
CARL 64. Carlton (received from Geelong)
SYD 65. Sydney
STK 66. St Kilda (received from Port Adelaide)
COLL 67. Collingwood
WCE 68. West Coast (received from Hawthorn via on-trades)
ADEL 69. Adelaide (received from Melbourne)
GWS 70. Greater Western Sydney 
WCE 71. West Coast
RICH 72. Richmond

CARL 73. Carlton
GCFC 74. Gold Coast
BL 75. Brisbane
STK 76. St Kilda
WB 77. Western Bulldogs
FRE 78. Fremantle
ADEL 79. Adelaide
ESS 80. Essendon
NMFC 81. North Melbourne
GEEL 82. Geelong
SYD 83. Sydney
PORT 84. Port Adelaide
COLL 85. Collingwood
HAW 86. Hawthorn
MELB 87. Melbourne
GWS 88. Greater Western Sydney 
WCE 89. West Coast
RICH 90. Richmond

AFL Draft Value Index

Pick/Pts Pick/Pts Pick/Pts Pick/Pts Pick/Pts
1. 3000 19. 948 37. 483 55. 207 73. 9
2. 2517 20. 912 38. 465 56. 194 74. -
3. 2234 21. 878 39. 446 57. 182  
4. 2034 22. 845 40. 429 58. 170  
5. 1878 23. 815 41. 412 59. 158  
6. 1751 24. 785 42. 395 60. 146  
7. 1644 25. 756 43. 378 61. 135  
8. 1551 26. 729 44. 362 62. 123  
9. 1469 27. 703 45. 347 63. 112  
10. 1395 28. 677 46. 331 64. 101  
11. 1329 29. 653 47. 316 65. 90  
12. 1268 30. 629 48. 302 66. 80  
13. 1212 31. 606 49. 287 67. 69  
14. 1161 32. 584 50. 273 68. 59  
15. 1112 33. 563 51. 259 69. 49  
16. 1067 34. 542 52. 246 70. 39  
17. 1025 35. 522 53. 233 71. 29  
18. 985 36. 502 54. 220 72. 19  

The views in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of the AFL or its clubs